Berggren | Our Clients

Proven European patent opens up international business potential for Smart Heating

Written by Smart Heating Oy | Nov 18, 2026, 7:02:28 AM

Smart Heating Oy provides hybrid heating and cooling solutions that improve energy efficiency for housing companies, the public sector and industrial customers. The company's solutions help customers reduce energy costs, increase the use of renewable energy and lower carbon emissions from buildings. Berggren has been Smart Heating's IP partner since 2017. Over the years, the collaboration has included two separate patent applications and the successful defence of a granted patent.

Smart Heating designs each system according to the customer's needs and the specific characteristics of the property. The solutions may incorporate heat recovery from exhaust air, waste heat recovery from commercial refrigeration systems or data centres, geothermal heating, district heating, ground cooling, patented heat recovery-based cooling, solar energy and battery technologies. The selection and combination of these technologies for each property create an energy-efficient hybrid system, controlled and optimised through extensive automation.

Pertti Nissilä, CEO, Smart Heating Oy

"We have developed our own software for controlling, monitoring and optimising building heating and cooling systems. We act as a turnkey solution provider, managing projects from design and equipment procurement through to installation. In addition to project delivery, we offer remote monitoring, support and maintenance services to ensure that energy systems operate efficiently and perform optimally throughout their lifecycle," explains Pertti Nissilä, CEO of Smart Heating.

European patent protects innovation in key target markets

The cooling solution developed by Smart Heating and patented in collaboration with Berggren is designed particularly for apartment buildings equipped with mechanical exhaust ventilation. The solution integrates apartment cooling into an exhaust air heat recovery system, making it possible to install a centralised cooling system alongside an investment that improves the building's heating efficiency.

"In our cooling solution, a cooling distribution network is installed in the apartment building's stairwell. Cooling energy generated by a heat pump is then distributed through this network to fan coil units in individual apartments. The system provides comfortable indoor conditions during the summer while improving the building's energy efficiency through exhaust air heat recovery. A single investment can therefore improve living comfort, increase property value and reduce energy consumption," Nissilä explains.

The cooling solution is protected by a European patent that provides sufficiently broad protection in Smart Heating's key target markets. As summers become hotter across Europe due to climate change and the population continues to age, the need for residential cooling solutions is increasing.

"We want to ensure that the innovation we have developed is protected in markets where we see significant potential for future growth," Nissilä emphasises.

Trust in expertise proved valuable during challenging opposition proceedings

Obtaining the European patent was not entirely straightforward. Shortly after the patent was granted, a competitor filed an opposition against it. As the patent was a European patent, the opposition was handled by the European Patent Office (EPO). Berggren had supported Smart Heating throughout the patent application process and continued the collaboration as preparations for the opposition proceedings began.

"Defending our patent against the opposition was naturally a tense experience. We discussed the situation realistically with Berggren's patent attorney several times, which gave us the confidence to fully commit to defending our patent. The opposing party turned out to be exceptionally confrontational and aggressive," Nissilä recalls.

Shortly before the oral proceedings, the patent attorney responsible for Smart Heating's case changed, and Jorma Vanhala from Berggren took over. The change at such a critical stage initially caused some concern, but confidence in the new expert was quickly established.

"The change of patent attorney just before the opposition hearing came as a bit of a shock at first. I had a discussion with Jorma to get a sense of his approach and attitude. That conversation reassured me and strengthened my confidence at this important stage. Looking back, I am very pleased that Jorma handled the opposition proceedings," Nissilä recalls.

Thorough preparation and strong expertise secured a successful outcome

The opposition was heard in oral proceedings conducted by videoconference. The hearing, led by the EPO's Opposition Division, was attended by representatives of the opposing party, as well as Smart Heating's representatives and Berggren's patent attorney. Under the EPO's direction, the parties examined the arguments presented for revoking the patent, with both sides presenting their positions. The proceedings were lengthy, lasting approximately eight hours in total. Ultimately, the competitor's opposition was rejected.

"The oral hearing was a unique experience for both me and our entire team. Jorma and our own technical expert, Arto Nissilä, prepared exceptionally thoroughly, which was reflected in their strong expertise and command of the situation. Jorma had focused on precisely the questions and arguments that were most relevant to the outcome of the case, and he managed to keep the discussion on track throughout the hearing. This was particularly important when the opposing party tried to steer the discussion in different directions and introduced new arguments even during the proceedings," Nissilä explains.

After the opposition proceedings, there was naturally a great sense of relief. The lengthy process had come to an end, and the patent had successfully withstood the challenge. Smart Heating has since been able to begin marketing the patented product, and the solution has already been successfully piloted at several sites.

"The saying 'What doesn't kill you makes you stronger' certainly applies here. Our patent has now been tested and proven strong, giving us the confidence to market our cooling solution freely. Before the opposition proceedings were concluded, we still had some concerns. Our core product, an intelligent exhaust air heat recovery system, can now be complemented with a cooling feature, which gives us a significant competitive advantage. Of course, the greatest opportunity may eventually lie in export markets," Nissilä says.

Clear and understandable communication builds trust

According to Nissilä, the collaboration with Berggren was extremely smooth throughout the patent process. When preparing for the opposition proceedings in particular, he appreciated Jorma's ability to explain the different stages of the process clearly and understandably, without unnecessary patent jargon.

"Although the matter was complex and largely unfamiliar to us, we always knew where we stood and what would happen next. To me, true expertise means having a deep understanding of your field while also being able to explain even complicated matters in clear, everyday language. When talking with Jorma, we never had to worry about getting lost in technical terms or patent terminology. Everything was explained in a way that was easy to understand. This built trust throughout the process and allowed us to focus on what mattered most," Nissilä explains.

"I have always considered Berggren one of the leading companies in its field, and our collaboration has only strengthened that impression," he concludes.


Our client experience story has been independently produced by Kokemuksia.fi. Each story has been approved by the interviewed client, and the company featured has had no opportunity to influence the content of the story.